Does Galatians Teach That God's Law Was Abolished? What Paul Was Really Addressing

|Beth Estevis
Galatians and Acts 15 Bible study exploring circumcision, Torah, and salvation through faith

If you've ever shared that you're learning to honor Shabbat, studying Torah, or observing YHWH's appointed times, there's a good chance someone has responded with one word:

Galatians.

And I understand why.

Paul uses strong language in this letter. He warns against seeking justification through the Law, speaks about freedom in Messiah, and challenges believers who were considering circumcision.

But here's the question I believe we need to ask before building an entire theology around those warnings:

What was happening in Galatia that caused Paul to write such an urgent letter?

Because if we don't understand the problem Paul was confronting, we risk applying his answer to a different question altogether.

Begin with Acts 15: What was the controversy?

Acts 15:1 gives us a remarkably clear statement of the issue.

Certain men from Judea were teaching Gentile believers that they could not be saved unless they were circumcised according to the custom of Moses.

Think about what that meant.

Gentiles were hearing the gospel, coming to faith in Yeshua, and receiving the Holy Spirit.

Yet some believers insisted that physical circumcision was necessary for their salvation and full acceptance among God's people.

Acts 15:5 shows that the disagreement also involved the wider question of Gentiles being instructed to keep the Law of Moses.

This was more than a disagreement over a religious custom.

It concerned salvation, covenant membership, and the relationship between Jewish and Gentile believers.

And it was serious enough that the apostles and elders gathered in Jerusalem to address it.

What did Peter say?

In Acts 15:7–11, Peter reminds the assembly of what YHWH had already done among the Gentiles.

He had given them the Holy Spirit and purified their hearts by faith.

Peter asks why they would place a yoke upon the Gentile disciples when salvation comes through the grace of the Lord Yeshua.

Notice what had already happened.

YHWH received the Gentile believers before they underwent physical circumcision.

Their acceptance wasn't waiting upon a procedure.

Their faith in Messiah was not incomplete because they had not become Jewish proselytes.

The Jerusalem Council then provided instructions for Gentile believers in Acts 15:19–21. Those instructions and their implications deserve careful study, but one conclusion is unmistakable: the apostles did not make physical circumcision a prerequisite for Gentiles to receive salvation.

Now carry that understanding into Galatians.

Paul's warning about circumcision

In Galatians 5:2–4, Paul directly addresses circumcision and warns against seeking justification through the Law.

These are some of the strongest words in the letter.

But we must pay attention to why circumcision had become such a serious issue.

Paul wasn't simply discussing a medical procedure. He was confronting reliance upon circumcision as a means of securing justification and covenant standing before YHWH.

This distinction matters.

In Acts 16:3, Paul circumcised Timothy, whose mother was Jewish. Yet Galatians 2:3–5 explains that Titus, a Greek, was not compelled to be circumcised.

Why treat these situations differently?

That's a question worth studying carefully.

The context suggests that the purpose and circumstances of circumcision mattered greatly, particularly when someone was insisting that it was necessary for salvation.

Paul was opposing justification through circumcision and works of the Law, not declaring YHWH's instructions evil.

Abraham was counted righteous before circumcision

To understand Paul's argument, we must go even further back.

In Genesis 15:6, Abraham believed YHWH, and that faith was counted to him as righteousness.

His circumcision came later, in Genesis 17.

Paul returns to Abraham repeatedly because his story establishes something foundational.

Righteousness was not first granted to Abraham because he had undergone physical circumcision.

He believed YHWH.

Romans 4:9–12 develops this point, and Galatians 3:6–9 connects Abraham's faith with the blessing extending to the nations.

Then Galatians 3:26–29 declares that those who belong to Messiah are Abraham's descendants and heirs according to the promise.

Think about that.

Gentile believers don't need a new ethnic identity to become heirs.

Our standing in Messiah is established through faith, not through a physical mark that makes us acceptable to YHWH.

Does that mean His commandments no longer matter?

This is where I believe the conversation often takes an unfortunate turn.

We hear that we are not justified by works of the Law, and then we conclude that obedience to YHWH's instructions must somehow oppose grace.

But is that what Scripture teaches?

Consider Romans 3:31.

Paul asks whether faith makes the Law void and answers that it does not.

Consider Romans 7:12, where he describes the Law as holy and the commandment as holy, righteous, and good.

And consider Galatians 5:13–14.

Even while teaching freedom in Messiah, Paul warns believers not to use that liberty as an opportunity for the flesh. He then draws directly from Leviticus 19:18 to teach love of neighbor.

Why would Paul appeal to Torah when instructing Gentile believers about how to live?

Because freedom in Messiah is not permission to walk in selfishness or sin.

Grace and obedience are not enemies. Salvation is not earned by our works, but faith is meant to bear fruit in how we live.

What about the Law being our guardian?

Galatians 3:23–25 is another passage that deserves careful attention.

Paul describes the Law as a guardian until Messiah came and says that believers are no longer under that guardian in the same way.

This is significant. Paul really is describing a change brought about through Messiah.

We shouldn't minimize that change or pretend nothing happened under the New Covenant.

But we should also ask what specific role the guardian played in Paul's argument.

Does the end of that custodial role mean every instruction of YHWH is now contrary to faith?

Or is Paul explaining that the Law could not provide the justification and inheritance that come through Messiah?

These questions require us to read Galatians 3 as a complete argument, beginning with Abraham and continuing through the promise, the Law, and the coming of Messiah.

What about days, months, seasons, and years?

Galatians 4:8–11 is frequently brought into conversations about Shabbat and the biblical feast days.

Paul expresses concern that the Galatians are observing particular days, months, seasons, and years.

Does that mean YHWH's appointed times have become wrong for believers to observe?

There are different interpretations of this passage.

Some understand Paul to be warning against a return to former pagan observances. Others believe he is addressing Jewish calendar observances adopted in a way that made them part of a system of religious justification. Still others see a broader warning about reliance upon sacred calendars.

The immediate context includes Paul's reminder that the Galatians had formerly served those that were not gods (Galatians 4:8).

That context deserves attention.

But I also believe we need to consider what Paul says elsewhere before declaring that the biblical appointed times themselves have become something evil.

The fact that Paul criticizes a particular manner of observance does not, by itself, establish that honoring the days YHWH set apart is forbidden.

This is precisely why we need to study the entire passage carefully rather than making a single verse carry more than it says.

What did YHWH promise about the New Covenant?

Now consider Jeremiah 31:31–34.

YHWH announces a New Covenant with the house of Israel and the house of Judah.

And in describing that covenant, He says He will put His Law within His people and write it upon their hearts.

What a remarkable promise.

The New Covenant is not merely an external adjustment. It concerns the heart, the knowledge of YHWH, and the forgiveness of sins.

Ezekiel 36:26–27 likewise speaks of a new heart and the Spirit enabling God's people to walk in His ways.

And Romans 8:3–4 connects the work of Messiah and the Spirit with the righteous requirement of the Law being fulfilled in those who walk according to the Spirit.

We are not trying to earn salvation by carrying the Law externally. We are seeking to live from hearts being transformed through the work of YHWH's Spirit.

The Law of Messiah and the fruit of love

By the time we reach Galatians 6, Paul has not abandoned the importance of righteousness, love, or faithful living.

In Galatians 6:1, he instructs spiritually mature believers to restore someone caught in wrongdoing with gentleness.

In Galatians 6:2, he tells believers to carry one another's burdens and fulfill the law of Messiah.

In Galatians 6:6, he speaks about sharing good things with those who teach the Word.

And in Galatians 6:7–9, he reminds believers that what we sow matters.

Notice how practical this becomes.

Our freedom should produce love.

Our understanding should produce humility.

Our obedience should be visible in the way we treat people.

It is possible to know the terminology of Torah and still fail to love our neighbor.

And it is possible to defend grace while treating YHWH's instructions as though they have nothing good to teach us.

Neither is the picture of maturity Paul presents.

One new man: Jew and Gentile together in Messiah

There's one more connection I believe we cannot overlook.

Galatians 3:28 teaches that Jew and Greek share equal standing in Messiah.

Ephesians 2:11–22 describes those who were once far off being brought near and made members of one household.

Ephesians 2:15 also raises important questions about the Law and ordinances under the New Covenant, which believers interpret differently and should study carefully.

Then Romans 11 gives us the beautiful picture of the cultivated olive tree.

Gentile believers are grafted in.

They do not replace the natural branches, and Paul specifically warns against boasting over them.

Being grafted in doesn't make us superior, nor does it require us to erase the Jewish identity and historical context of the Messiah we follow.

The goal is not to create two classes of believers.

Nor is it to require Gentiles to become ethnically Jewish.

It is to recognize that through Yeshua, those who were once far off have been brought near.

One household. One Messiah. One faith.

So what was Paul really teaching?

I believe Galatians is a powerful defense of justification through faith in Messiah rather than through circumcision and works of the Law.

It also teaches us that freedom cannot become permission for sin, that the Spirit must shape our lives, and that love must be evident in our relationships.

There are genuine interpretive questions about how individual Torah commandments apply under the New Covenant. Those deserve honest examination of all the relevant passages.

But I do not believe Galatians should be used to dismiss the entire Torah as though YHWH's previous revelation were something believers needed to escape.

We don't study Torah to purchase our salvation.

We study it because it is part of the Word of YHWH, because it teaches us about His character, and because it continually points us toward Messiah.

We're not trying to earn our place in the family. We're learning how to walk as children who already belong to the Father through Yeshua.

And we're still learning, too.

That's why I want to encourage you to read Galatians again—slowly, prayerfully, and alongside Acts 15.

Don't begin with a conclusion you've heard repeated.

Begin with the text.

Ask who Paul was addressing, what problem he was correcting, and how his words fit within the testimony of the whole of Scripture.

You may discover that there's much more to this letter than you've been taught.


Continue studying with us

For a shorter introduction, visit our Common Questions: Galatians, Acts 15, and the Law page.

Ready to go deeper? Our Galatians in Context workbook walks through the whole letter in 13 sessions, reading Paul alongside Acts, the Torah and the Prophets (instant PDF download, $14.99).

And if you're beginning to explore Shabbat and YHWH's appointed times, our free Shabbat Watch offers Your First 8 Sabbaths, a Scripture-centered journey to help you get started.

Join Shabbat Watch — Free

From our table to yours, Shabbat Shalom!
Beth & Daniel
We Be Shabbatin'