Does Romans 14 Mean the Sabbath Doesn't Matter?

|Beth Estevis
Open Bible showing Romans 14 and Colossians 2 on a Shabbat table with challah, candles, and an olive branch

Romans 14, Colossians 2, and the Sabbath: Reading Paul in Context

Shalom, friend.

It happens almost every time we post about Shabbat or the biblical feasts. Someone kindly (or not so kindly) drops a verse in the comments.

Romans 14:5. Colossians 2:16. Sometimes Mark 7.

We get it. These passages come up so frequently that they've almost become shorthand for one particular conclusion: "Paul said the days don't matter anymore."

But is that really what he said?

Daniel and I aren't writing this to win a debate. We're writing because we've wrestled with these same passages ourselves. And when we began reading them in their full context, we started asking questions we hadn't considered before.

So let's sit down, open the Word, and take a closer look.

Start Where Paul Starts

The best way to understand any chapter is to let it tell us what it's about.

Romans 14 begins this way:

"As for the one whose faith is weak, accept him [into your fellowship], but not for [the purpose of] quarreling over his opinions." — Romans 14:1 (AMP)

Paul begins with disagreements over opinions—matters believers were disputing.

And what's his first example?

"One man's faith permits him to eat everything, while the weak believer eats only vegetables..." — Romans 14:2 (AMP)

Meat or vegetables.

Why would something like that divide believers?

Food was a significant issue in the early assemblies. Questions surrounding ritual purity, shared meals, and meat associated with idol worship all formed part of the religious world these believers inhabited.

Paul addresses food offered to idols directly in 1 Corinthians 8–10, although Romans 14 doesn't tell us precisely why some believers chose to abstain from meat.

What we do know is that some were eating, others were abstaining, and they were judging one another over it.

That's where Paul's instruction begins.

So What "Days" Was Paul Talking About?

Now we come to the verse everyone quotes.

"One person regards one day as better [or more important] than another, while another regards every day [the same as any other]. Let everyone be fully convinced (assured, satisfied) in his own mind." — Romans 14:5 (AMP)

Here's something worth noticing.

The word Sabbath never appears in Romans 14. Not once.

Paul refers to particular days without explicitly identifying which days were being disputed.

And that raises an important question.

What days would believers in the first century have considered special apart from the weekly Sabbath?

One possibility is customary fasting days.

In Luke 18:12, Yeshua describes a Pharisee who declares that he fasts twice a week.

Those twice-weekly fasts were not commanded in the Torah.

We also have an early Christian writing called the Didache, which describes different communities observing different fasting days. Some fasted on Monday and Thursday, while others were instructed to fast on Wednesday and Friday.

Now, the Didache isn't Scripture. And its description doesn't prove that Romans 14 was specifically about fasting.

But it does help us understand that disputes over customary days of religious observance were a real part of the early believing community.

Some interpreters understand Romans 14:5–6 in this light. Others believe Paul was addressing Jewish festival observance more broadly.

We should acknowledge those possibilities because Paul doesn't explicitly settle the question for us.

But consider what he does say.

Verse 6 connects the discussion of days with eating and abstaining, and the larger chapter repeatedly instructs believers not to despise or judge one another.

Paul's unmistakable concern is how believers are treating one another over these disagreements.

What he doesn't explicitly do is identify the Sabbath that YHWH blessed at creation and announce that it has been abolished.

Genesis 2:3 tells us YHWH blessed and sanctified the seventh day.

Exodus 20:8–11 commands Israel to remember the Sabbath and keep it holy.

And Leviticus 23:3 identifies the weekly Shabbat among YHWH's appointed times.

For us, that raises a question worth considering:

Should a passage about unspecified days be used, by itself, to set aside a day Scripture specifically identifies as holy?

We don't believe it should.

That doesn't mean Romans 14 answers every question about Sabbath observance under the New Covenant. It means we should be careful about making the passage say more than Paul actually wrote.

And we should remember his instruction not to judge or despise one another.

Obedience isn't legalism. But treating our own opinions and customs as though YHWH commanded them is a line we should be careful not to cross.

Colossians 2:16–17 — A Shadow of Things to Come

Colossians 2 is the other passage we hear most often.

Paul writes:

"Therefore let no one judge you in regard to food and drink or in regard to [the observance of] a festival or a new moon or a Sabbath day." — Colossians 2:16 (AMP)

Then he explains that these things are a shadow, while the substance belongs to Messiah.

There are two parts of this passage I want us to consider.

"Let No One Judge You"

First, notice Paul's instruction.

He's telling the Colossians not to allow others to judge them concerning these matters.

The congregation included Gentile believers who had come to faith in Messiah (Colossians 1:27; 2:13).

But who was doing the judging, and why?

Look at the surrounding verses.

In Colossians 2:8, Paul warns against human tradition and teachings that are not according to Messiah.

Then in verses 20–23, he challenges restrictive religious regulations, including prohibitions on handling, tasting, and touching, and identifies them with human commandments and teachings.

Paul is clearly concerned about humanly imposed religious regulations.

That's important context.

He doesn't explicitly instruct the Colossians to stop observing Shabbat or the feasts.

Some Christians understand this passage as teaching that these observances are no longer obligatory under the New Covenant. Others, including us, understand Paul's warning as opposing human judgments and regulations rather than abolishing YHWH's appointed times.

The passage doesn't tell us precisely how each believer in Colossae observed these days, so we shouldn't pretend to know everything about the circumstances.

But we can recognize what Paul is emphasizing.

Their confidence was to remain in Messiah, not in the authority of human religious rules.

And I don't believe Colossians 2 should become a weapon for shaming believers who desire to honor the appointed times.

"A Shadow of Things to Come"

Now this part is especially meaningful to me.

Paul calls these things a shadow, and identifies Messiah as the substance.

Some translations use the wording "things to come," while others understand the expression in relation to what was anticipated before Messiah's first coming.

That wording alone doesn't settle whether Paul is referring to future prophetic fulfillment, fulfillment already accomplished in Messiah, or both.

But it does tell us something essential.

Messiah is the reality to whom these things point.

And isn't that precisely why the appointed times are so meaningful?

Passover directs our attention to redemption and the Lamb of God.

Shavuot brings us into the story of covenant, harvest, and the outpouring of the Spirit.

And Shabbat reminds us of the Creator who blessed the seventh day and calls His people to cease from their labor.

For Daniel and me, discovering the ways these appointed times point to Yeshua hasn't made them less meaningful.

It's made us want to understand them more deeply.

We don't observe them as a replacement for Messiah.

We seek to honor them because they continually direct our attention back to Him.

A shadow doesn't compete with the substance.

It points us toward the reality.

And that reality is Yeshua.

The Golden Calf: A Feast "to YHWH" That He Never Asked For

There's a story at Sinai that helps me think carefully about the difference between what YHWH establishes and what people create in worship.

While Moses was on the mountain, the people pressured Aaron, and he made a golden calf.

Then something remarkable happened.

Aaron built an altar before it and announced:

"Tomorrow shall be a feast to the LORD!" — Exodus 32:5 (AMP)

In the Hebrew, the name used there is YHWH.

Think about that.

They attached His name to the celebration.

They called it a feast to Him.

Yet YHWH rejected what they had done.

Now, let's be clear. The golden calf involved idolatry. We shouldn't suggest that every human custom or uncommanded celebration is automatically equivalent to making an idol.

But the passage teaches a sobering principle:

Attaching YHWH's name to something doesn't automatically make it acceptable worship.

And that brings us to Deuteronomy 12:30–32.

YHWH warned Israel not to imitate the ways the nations worshiped their gods, and He instructed His people not to add to or take away from what He commanded.

That's why we believe examining our inherited practices matters.

Not because every custom is wrong.

But because His Word must remain the authority by which we examine what we do in His name.

A Quick Word About Mark 7

Mark 7 often comes into this conversation, especially verse 19, where many English translations say that Yeshua declared all foods clean.

But before we get to verse 19, let's go back to the beginning of the chapter.

The Pharisees were upset because some of Yeshua's disciples were eating without following the customary ritual washing of hands.

Mark identifies this as the tradition of the elders (Mark 7:3–5).

This wasn't simply about washing dirt off their hands before dinner.

It involved ritual purity practices that had developed within Jewish religious life.

The specific handwashing requirement being disputed was not a Torah command for ordinary meals.

These practices were transmitted through the traditions of the elders. Related rules were later preserved in the Mishnah, compiled around 200 CE, and discussed further in rabbinic literature, including the Talmud.

The Mishnah's tractate Yadayim contains detailed discussions of ritual handwashing.

So we're dealing with a real historical practice, not something Yeshua invented as an illustration.

What Was Yeshua Correcting?

In Mark 7:8–13, Yeshua rebukes the religious leaders for elevating human traditions in ways that set aside God's commandments.

He even provides an example involving the command to honor father and mother.

That's significant.

He was confronting religious practices that interfered with obedience to the Word of God.

Now, Mark 7:19 does raise another question.

Many English translations understand the closing phrase as Mark explaining that Yeshua declared all foods clean.

Other interpreters argue that the phrase should be understood within Yeshua's discussion of ritual defilement, without necessarily abolishing the distinction between clean and unclean animals.

That is a genuine interpretive disagreement, and it deserves a careful study of its own.

But the immediate conversation began with ritual handwashing, and Yeshua's central teaching directs our attention to the heart, from which evil thoughts and sinful actions arise.

What we should never overlook is His warning against allowing human traditions to override God's commandments.

And that principle is just as important for us today.

Learning the Difference Between Customs and Commandments

I'll share a little something from our own journey.

When Daniel and I first started observing Shabbat, I remember stressing about finding challah bread.

Our grocery store didn't sell it, and if I'm being honest, I didn't even know what challah was!

I had seen it in pictures of beautiful Shabbat tables, and I thought that if we were going to do Shabbat the right way, surely we needed that bread.

But I hadn't even stopped to understand why it was there.

Later, I learned about the traditional two loaves and how they commemorate the double portion of manna YHWH provided on the sixth day (Exodus 16).

What a beautiful reminder of His faithfulness!

But the braided bread itself isn't a commandment.

I was trying to copy what I had seen before I understood what it meant.

That experience has stayed with me.

We still enjoy meaningful customs around our Shabbat table.

But we want to be careful never to give those customs the authority of YHWH's commandments.

And that's the same standard we want to apply to everything we teach through We Be Shabbatin'.

Reading Together, Not Judging Each Other

I want to say this plainly.

Many people we love read these passages differently.

We're not declaring that everyone who disagrees with us is a sinner, nor are we claiming that every question surrounding the New Covenant has been answered in this one article.

What we are encouraging is a return to the Scriptures.

Read Romans 14 in its entirety.

Read Colossians 2, not just verses 16 and 17.

Go back to Genesis 2, Exodus 20, and Leviticus 23.

Read how Yeshua walked, what He taught, and how He responded when religious tradition came into conflict with the commandments of God.

And ask the Father for understanding.

We don't believe keeping Shabbat or observing the appointed times earns salvation.

Salvation is a gift of grace through Yeshua our Messiah. Obedience is our loving response to Him, not the price we pay to receive Him.

And for Daniel and me, Shabbat has become one of the most beautiful parts of learning to order our lives around His Word.

Not a burden we're trying to carry.

A set-apart day we're learning to honor.

A gift our Creator established long before we ever knew to look for it.

We're still learning, too.

And we'd love for you to keep opening the Word alongside us.

Want to Study These Passages More Deeply?

We've put together a Scripture reference exploring Romans 14, Colossians 2, Mark 7, and the distinction between YHWH's commandments and human traditions.

Read the Full Scripture Study: Romans 14 and Colossians 2

Curious About Beginning Shabbat?

You don't need a perfect table, a vocabulary of Hebrew words, or every question answered before taking your first step.

Our free Shabbat Watch sends weekly reminders with your local Shabbat start time, along with an eight-week journey to help you begin learning the rhythm of the seventh day.

Join Shabbat Watch — It's Free

With love from our table,
Beth & Daniel
We Be Shabbatin'
Shabbat by Shabbat. Scripture by Scripture.