Part Four of A Conversation Worth Having — The Name, the Roots & the Family

There's a question I've been returning to as I study Galatians.
What if we've spent so much time reading Paul as though he were arguing against Moses that we've overlooked how frequently he actually reasons from Moses?
I know how familiar the objections can sound.
"But Paul said we're not under the Law."
"Didn't Galatians tell us we're free from all of that?"
"Why return to Moses when we have Messiah?"
Those questions deserve thoughtful answers. Paul makes strong statements about the Law, circumcision, justification, and freedom. We shouldn't soften them to protect our preferred interpretations.
But neither should we begin by assuming that Moses and Paul stand on opposite sides of the gospel.
Instead, let's open Galatians and ask a different question.
Which Scriptures did Paul use to make his argument?
First, understand the controversy
Acts 15:1 records certain men teaching that Gentile believers needed to be circumcised according to the custom of Moses in order to be saved.
The wider discussion also involved questions about Gentiles keeping the Law of Moses (Acts 15:5).
This was not a minor disagreement about family customs.
It concerned salvation, covenant belonging, and what Gentiles needed to do to be fully received among the people of YHWH.
Peter reminded the Jerusalem assembly that YHWH had already given the Holy Spirit to Gentiles and purified their hearts by faith (Acts 15:7–11).
Paul's letter to the Galatians addresses closely related concerns.
When circumcision becomes something people trust in for justification, Paul responds forcefully.
But how does he explain his position?
He returns to Abraham.
When Paul wanted to explain faith, he went to Genesis
In Galatians 3:6, Paul draws from Genesis 15:6.
Abraham believed YHWH, and his faith was counted to him as righteousness.
Think about the chronology.
Abraham's faith was counted as righteousness before he received the covenant sign of circumcision in Genesis 17.
Paul develops this point further in Romans 4.
His argument is not disconnected from Moses.
The Torah itself records that Abraham was counted righteous before circumcision.
When Paul explains how Gentiles receive the blessing promised to Abraham, he again returns to Genesis and the promise that the nations would be blessed through him (Galatians 3:8; Genesis 12:3).
Paul is explaining the gospel through the story YHWH had already revealed.
When Paul wanted to explain the curse, he went to Deuteronomy
Galatians 3:10–14 is one of the strongest passages in Paul's argument.
And look at his sources.
He draws upon Deuteronomy 27:26 concerning the curse associated with failing to uphold the words of the Law.
He uses Leviticus 18:5 when discussing doing what the Law requires.
He draws upon Deuteronomy 21:23 to explain Messiah bearing the curse in connection with being hung upon a tree.
Paul also quotes Habakkuk 2:4 when discussing righteousness through faith.
These passages form the foundation of his reasoning about the Law's demands, faith, and Messiah's redemptive work.
This doesn't mean Paul is simply repeating Moses without drawing any new conclusions.
Far from it.
He is interpreting the earlier Scriptures in light of what Yeshua has accomplished.
But that is precisely what makes his argument worth studying.
Paul doesn't dismiss the Scriptures of Moses as irrelevant. He uses them to explain why Messiah's saving work is necessary.
"Do you not listen to the Law?"
I find Galatians 4:21 especially striking.
Paul addresses those who desire to be under the Law and asks whether they actually listen to what the Law says.
And what does he do next?
He tells the story of Hagar, Sarah, Ishmael, and Isaac.
He goes back to Genesis.
He uses that story to explain the distinction between slavery and freedom, between relying upon the flesh and receiving the promise.
His allegorical interpretation raises questions of its own, and faithful readers differ about some of its details.
But one thing is clear.
When Paul wants to challenge his readers' understanding, he calls their attention to the Torah.
That should make us cautious about presenting Paul and Moses as though one must defeat the other.
When Paul wanted to explain love, he quoted Leviticus
Now move to Galatians 5.
Paul has spoken powerfully about freedom in Messiah.
But in Galatians 5:13, he warns believers not to use that freedom as an opportunity for the flesh.
Instead, they are to serve one another through love.
And in the very next verse, he quotes Leviticus 19:18 concerning loving our neighbors as ourselves.
I love this connection.
When Paul teaches believers how their freedom should be expressed, he points them to an instruction already found in Torah.
Why?
Because freedom is not an excuse for selfishness.
And love is not simply a feeling that replaces faithful conduct.
Paul's instruction reveals continuity between the character of YHWH expressed in Torah and the life of believers walking by the Spirit.
Grace does not turn selfishness into love. The Spirit transforms the way we live.
But what about the passages where Paul says the Law's role has changed?
We need to address these honestly.
Galatians 3:23–25 describes the Law as a guardian and speaks of a change now that faith has come.
Galatians 5:2–4 warns those seeking justification through circumcision and the Law that they are turning away from reliance upon Messiah's grace.
These passages matter.
We cannot simply quote Romans 3:31, where Paul speaks of faith establishing the Law, and pretend the difficult passages don't exist.
Nor should we quote Galatians 5:4 and conclude that everything YHWH instructed Israel to do must therefore be spiritually worthless.
We need to examine Paul's arguments in their full context.
His teaching about justification, inheritance, covenant membership, and the coming of Messiah brings genuine change.
But the existence of that change does not automatically mean Paul considered the Torah evil.
In Romans 7:12, he calls the Law holy and the commandment holy, righteous, and good.
So rather than forcing every passage into a simple formula, we should ask:
What role does Paul assign to the Law, and how does he understand that role in light of Messiah?
That's a much more fruitful starting point.
What if we've inherited the wrong question?
This is what I've been pondering.
What if we have been taught to begin with the question, "Why did Paul oppose Moses?"
But Paul was never writing as a man who believed Israel's Scriptures were a mistake.
He was reasoning from those Scriptures to proclaim the Messiah.
The question isn't whether Paul quoted Moses. He clearly did.
The question is what conclusions he drew and how faithfully we understand them.
And this brings me back to Luke 24:27.
After His resurrection, Yeshua began with Moses and the Prophets and explained the things concerning Himself throughout the Scriptures.
Yeshua opened Moses to reveal Himself.
Paul repeatedly drew from Moses to explain His saving work.
There is a continuity here that deserves far more attention than we sometimes give it.
A different way to read Galatians
Here's an invitation.
The next time you read Galatians, don't begin by collecting isolated verses that seem to settle the entire question of the Law.
Instead, trace the passages Paul quotes.
Read Genesis 15 alongside Galatians 3.
Read Deuteronomy 27 alongside Galatians 3:10.
Read Deuteronomy 21 alongside Galatians 3:13.
Read Genesis 16–21 alongside Galatians 4.
Read Leviticus 19 alongside Galatians 5.
Then ask what Paul is actually teaching through those connections.
Don't be afraid of passages that challenge your assumptions.
And don't be afraid to admit that some questions require more study.
We are not trying to earn our place in the family. We're learning how to walk as children who already belong to the Father through Messiah.
That's why this matters to me.
Not because I want to win an argument about Torah.
But because I want to understand the whole Word of YHWH and the Messiah it reveals.
Questions worth carrying forward
1. What was the specific controversy surrounding circumcision in Acts 15 and Galatians?
2. How does Abraham's chronology help Paul explain justification through faith?
3. What changes when we read Paul's Torah quotations in their original settings?
4. How can we hold together Paul's warnings about justification through the Law and his positive statements about YHWH's commandments?
5. Are we allowing Scripture to form our understanding, or are we reading familiar interpretations back into the text?
Perhaps the next time someone quotes Galatians to you, the most fruitful response won't be another isolated verse.
Perhaps it will be an invitation.
"Would you be willing to read the Scriptures Paul was quoting with me?"
From my table to yours, Shalom.
Beth Estevis
We Be Shabbatin'
WE BE SHABBATIN' · SCRIPTURE CONVERSATIONS
A Conversation Worth Having
The Name, the Roots & the Family
- Why Does the Name Yeshua Make Some Christians Uncomfortable? The invitation to an honest conversation.
- Yeshua and Jesus: Two Languages, One Messiah The historical and linguistic foundations.
- The New Testament Is Greek. Does That Make Its Hebrew Foundations Less Important? How the Scriptures are connected.
- Was Paul Arguing Against Moses—or Reasoning From Him? Following Paul's actual biblical reasoning. (You are here)
- Grafted In, Not Erased What belonging in Messiah means for Jew and Gentile.
Free Shabbat Watch
A practical invitation for readers who want to keep studying and begin walking out what they're learning.
“We are not asking you to abandon the Messiah you know. We're inviting you to discover more of the Scriptures that reveal Him.”
Continue the conversation
Previously: The New Testament Is Greek. Does That Make Its Hebrew Foundations Less Important?
Next: Grafted In, Not Erased
For a deeper study, explore our Galatians in Context workbook, a 13-session examination of Torah, covenant, faith, and freedom in Messiah.
If you're beginning your journey into Shabbat, join our free Shabbat Watch for Your First 8 Sabbaths.